Saturday, December 16, 2017

I am for free tertiary education done responsibly


I have noticed the way Jacob Zuma operates is very much like Robert Mugabe. He operates unilaterally; he surrounds himself with incompetent ministers and fires competent ministers. Like Mugabe, Zuma seems to think that a country can never go bankrupt. Zuma’s unilateral actions in announcing free higher education is meant to help his favoured faction without regard to the economy. After the court judgements of last week, I do not think Zuma still has the moral authority to continue ringing these far-reaching changes that will surely affect the economy. For the record as a person who came from a poor working class family, I support free funded government tertiary education done in a responsible way. I started primary school education a few years after Zimbabwe’s independence. My father before his death in 1990 was a police constable and my mother was not working. I went to township schools that were fully funded by the government and I have written in my blog how we used to pay only $6 Zimbabwean dollars per year as school fees up to grade 7. For secondary education, I also went to township schools and they were very cheap. I only went to a former group A or a previously whites only school during the days of segregation (equivalence of a model C school) for the two years of A’Level as the township schools in my town only went up to O’level at that time.

After A’Level the government was fully funding university education and students were getting generous grants from the government as well. For those who did not go to university there were fully funded teachers’ colleges, polytechnic colleges, nursing training, apprenticeship, training as a radiographer etc. One could also join private sector or the civil service and get in house training. I then joined a South African owned Insurance company and I got trained internally and the company also paid for my foreign based insurance studies. After the collapse of the Zimbabwean economy starting with the fall of the Zimbabwean dollar in 1997, now university education is no longer free and university standards have fallen sharply. Top government ministers started sending their children to overseas universities to countries such as Australia, United Kingdom and United States. Now parents who can afford it now sends their children to South Africa as Zimbabwean universities standards have fallen and at the same time many university lecturers also left Zimbabwe due to the poor living standards in the country. Zimbabwe university degrees are no longer highly regarded. I am sure many people have read how Grace Mugabe got her doctorate in a record time of only a few months at the once prestigious University of Zimbabwe. I personally know someone who is working in South Africa who came to this country already with a Zimbabwean accounting degree and he is currently again studying for an accounting degree with a South African university just to get ahead in his career. With unemployment level of 95% in Zimbabwe, I advise my close family members to rather pursue their degrees in South Africa for better employment prospects. Two years ago a cousin of mine was complaining that her daughter was pursuing a degree at a Zimbabwe university of which there was virtually no industry for it in Zimbabwe and she could not get attachment in order to complete her degree.

Fully funded tertiary education is very important towards bridging the racial divide gap in South Africa especially as it allows the majority of the black citizens to acquire the necessary skills and also join the middle class. In Zimbabwe after independence a lot of black citizens managed to get training to become teachers, nurses, artisans, managers, lawyers, doctors, radiographers, economists etc. That is why it was far much easier for skilled Zimbabweans to settle in United Kingdom, Australia, New Zealand, Canada, South Africa, Botswana, Namibia etc. when the economy collapsed in Zimbabwe as they had the necessary skills thanks to the educational policies of the government. Whilst the government is pursuing that noble goal of skilling its people, it must still manage the country’s fiscus in a prudent manner so that those newly skilled black professionals join a growing economy. South African economy is not growing largely as a result of the way that Zuma has managed this country and there is looming downgrades, devaluation of the currency, high unemployment etc. I am very fearful of the reaction of the markets when they open on Monday. We can’t afford the continuous devaluation in the Rand. As we speak we are paying record petrol prices even though the oil price is nowhere nearer the $150 per barrel experienced on the world market a few years ago.

As a parent whose son will be going to university in about 3 years, I am also now looking for overseas university education or private university education locally. I had a front row seat in Zimbabwe when the decay started to manifest itself. South Africa seems to be going that way and I am very worried about what the future holds and the end result will be the same it’s a question of different cast but with the same script and it will certainly produce the same result.

Saturday, December 2, 2017

THE WORLD DOES NOT OWE ZIMBABWE ANYTHING


Before I went to bed on Thursday 30 November 2017 I had misplaced hope when it comes to Zimbabwe. I had picked up this hope on Saturday 18 November the day we marched to State House to demand Mugabe’s resignation. I had advised my wife that I had decided to go to Zimbabwe the following day with plans to spend more money in our piggery project and expand it further. My wife’s answer was that she was weary of us keeping on spending money in Zimbabwe as we had lost a lot of money in Zimbabwe in the past. The same week that Emmerson Munangagwa was fired, I had over a dozen pigs ready for market and we were battling to get buyers. The day after the general went on Zimbabwe TV to announce the coup that was not a coup, I started getting phone calls from Zimbabwe and a number of people wanted to buy the whole lot. I decided maybe lets increase the breeding stock and not sell and hopefully in 12 month time we might have a stock of 500 pigs and maybe invest in the butchery equipment and open our own butcheries in Zimbabwe as we constantly get raw deals from the guys we supply meat to. Is it a Southern African thing to have these cabinets announced just before midnight, look Zuma’s dubious cabinet reshuffles are always announced around midnight?

I woke up the following day and saw the cabinet and at first I thought it was just a joke. At 5am, I went out for my 5km morning run and when I came back my wife had also woken up and she had also read the news. I have since shelved my plans and it’s time to wait and see what happens in the next election. The rulers in Zimbabwe need to know that the world does not owe anything to Zimbabwe. Zimbabwe has to fight for and attract scarce resources from an open market. If I as a Zimbabwean am more comfortable to keep my hard earned money in a foreign country, do they expect a foreigner to come and invest?

Yesterday they were blaming Morgan Tsvangirai for their cabinet. Someone pointed out that if that is the case that Tsvangirai threatened his lieutenants not to join this cabinet why did they not consider other people outside MDC-T. In the previous GNU government there were many competent ministers who are not in Tsvangirai’s party, people such as Elton Mangoma, Tendai Biti, David Coltart, Whelsman Ncube, Priscilla Misihairabwi etc my question is why were they not considered? Also there are other Zanu -PF aligned MPs such as Temba Mliswa and Paul Mangwana to choose from.  There is also other qualified people such as Nkosana Moyo who were also not considered.

We had already decided as a family that we are not going to Zimbabwe this Christmas holiday as all our kids despise going to Zimbabwe. Although I have a lot of hope for Zimbabwe, I remember we used to say who ever comes after Mugabe cannot be worse and the economy will improve. However we need to see the world for what it is and not according to how we want it to be. If the economy does not improve, the generals can never win a free and fair election.

 

God bless Zimbabwe

Sunday, November 26, 2017

Why I am rooting for my new president

Everyone has a story to tell when it comes to Robert Mugabe. Like millions of Zimbabweans, I was resigned to the fact that Robert Mugabe would be my president until he dies. However it was the thought that Grace Mugabe would succeed him that that made me want to puke. To be honest Zimbabweans never really liked Grace Mugabe even years before she opened her mouth and uttered those taboo words. Second wives are always accused of taking another man's wife. I remember growing up in police camps and I would hear women saying,"akatora murume wemunhu" meaning she stole someone's man/husband. Obviously this is just perpetuation of patriarchy where only the second wife is blamed but not the husband who is thought of being helpless to the charms of the second wife. In all my stay in Zimbabwe, I had never experienced such behaviour as exhibited by Grace Mugabe from any lady. I had stayed with both my grandmothers, my mother, my mother in law, all my aunts, my sisters in law etc. and none of them had behaved like our former first lady. I had only noticed such behaviour from intoxicated people or those that had a mental illness. From 1989 to 1990 we had stayed at Mbizo Police station in Kwekwe and our house was right next to the gate and around 300 metres from the gate there was the council's Garandichauya bar. There ladies of the night would walk to and from the bar and when they were intoxicated they would shout obscenities.

 I had promised myself that after Mugabe dies in office, I would visit Heroes Acre once more to make sure that he is gone for good. This would be second time I would have visited the shrine. The only other time I visited Heroes Acre was in 1999 during the burial of Vice President Joshua Nkomo, I had gone to pay my respects to this great stateman, I walked all the way from Avondale. So on 18 November 2017, I woke up in Pretoria around midnight as I normally sleep only for a few hours. I started looking for any available flights to Harare. I had two challenges that morning, firstly to wake up my wife Manyoni and disturb her sleep, she loves her sleep very much and also to convince her that I was going to spend so much money that morning. My sales experience came in handy as I was on my way to O.R Tambo airport by 4am. I landed in Harare around 10am. As I disembarked from the taxi along Robert Mugabe road that morning, I kept on pinching myself to make sure that I was not dreaming,where all these people demonstrating against the all powerful and mighty Robert Mugabe for real?

Robert Mugabe Road in the morning of the demonstration
 I really wanted to go to Zimbabwe Grounds in Highfied for the gathering but I had to go home first to catch up on sleep and also to recharge my phone. Highfield has special significance for me as I was born at Harare hospital just a few kilometres away. In line with the Shona custom as the first child, I was supposed to be born at my mother's parents home in Murewa. When the days of my birth drew closer, my mother went to Murewa hospital. She then had complications and she was transferred to Salisbury as Harare was known then during the colonial era. The referral hospital for blacks was Harare Hospital also known as Kugomo and I was delivered there through ceasarian section. My father's uncle has a house in Highfield and also at that time my mother's eldest brother had bought a house in the nearby high density suburb of Glen Norah upon his return from Zambia with his Zambian wife and we alternated among the two houses. Growing up I was naughty and my mother always reminded me that as a child born via operation (ceasarian section) I should not give her so much grief as she had suffered so much for me and also that whenever the weather was cold she would feel the pain from that operation.

After lunch I took a taxi back to Harare city centre and started moving up the road with crowds of people along fourth street on the way to State House. I passed by Eagle House where I started my insurance career 20years ago. The special place for me was along Samora Machel avenue where the president's office is housed. In August 2007 in the company of my wife a few weeks before I left Zimbabwe to escape the dire economic situation and settle in Pretoria, I was assaulted by an armed police guard in the evening on our way back to Holiday Inn hotel from First Street. I had decided that it would be safer to pass through Samora Machel Avenue as it would be safe from any potential muggers due to the presence of armed guards.

Along Samora Machel Avenue


I eventually made it to within 100 metres of the State House and everyone was jovial and the soldiers were friendly. State House induces fear in many Zimbabweans, it is not like The Union Buildings here in Pretoria where families go there for a Sunday picnic. When I was working in Harare, I tried to avoid driving nearer to State House as much as possible. Manyoni was working in Borrowdale and my biggest client was also in Borrowdale so I had to go there most days. The most direct way to go to Borrowdale was to drive past State House. I would avoid the State House by either driving up Second street (now Sam Nujoma street) and then turn right towards the University of Zimbabwe campus or go via Newlands and then Highlands. The soldiers and police guarding State House are very brutal, I once saw a motorist being forced to push his car alone all the way past State House after it had broken down. I almost had a run in with the goons around 2004 when my company issued Mazda double cab bakkie stalled next to Prince Edward school on the corner of Princes road and Prince Edward street. Unbeknown to me the motor cade of Robert Mugabe was going to pass through that intersection on his way to Zanu-PF headquarters. Two men wearing suits whom I suspected to be members of the dreaded CIO stopped and ordered me to push my car off the road, I could not push the bakkie on my own as it was very heavy. After about 30 minutes another car stopped by and I explained to them that I could not push the car on my own and the two security officers then helped me to push the bakkie off the road.


A long suffering Arsenal fan in our midst



Banner asking Zimbabweans in the diaspora to come home


 I am rooting for our new President Mr Emmerson Munangagwa even though, I have consistently voted for Morgan Tsvangirai and his party since 2000. I was hoping that he was going to put together a transitional government for a few years and sort out the economy and postpone the elections. Myself as a farmer and businessman, his success is my success. I feel like the economic failures of Zimbabwe always follow me wherever I go. Zimbabwe should move away from being the skunk of Sourthern Africa. I am tired of being a foreigner. Being a foreigner is hard my friends. My experience has been always to expect the answer,"No", and when that answer is served, it always crashes my spirits. I long to be part of a society where I have equal opportunities like everyone else without anyone telling me that I do not qualify because I am not a citizen. I also want the same for my children as I worry that if they experience what I have experienced as a foreigner they might not handle it well.

On Sunday 2 September 2007 my brother in law was then pursuing his doctorate at University of Pretoria and also my youngest sister was pursuing her masters' degree at the same university. My brother in law asked me to accompany him to the main campus in Hatfield Pretoria. Whilst he was busy discussing with fellow PHD candidates who were all from other African countries and mostly Zimbabweans, I was reading the column by the late editor of Zimbabwe Standard newspaper Mr Bill Saidi. I then wrote to him recounting my story and on the following weekend he wrote the following  column http://www.zimbabwesituation.com/old/sep9a_2007.html#Z20

When optimism buys you zilch

Zim Standard

  sundayopinion by Bill Saidi

IN the evening, when you and your wife are walking back to your hotel,
after tucking into expensive but delicious pizza, it is downright
humiliating to be asked to lie down flat on your belly in the street.

Depending on your threshold of tolerance, you might decide there and
then to leave the country of your birth for the wild blue yonder.

Some people might call this over-reaction; others might, at a pinch,
propose that this display of cruelty to a man's dignity was the last straw.

Which is what it was for the man who wrote this to me last week:

"Events over the past three months left me with no choice. At the end
of June, I left my position as a branch manager of an insurance company. I
just wanted to concentrate on my business(es); three grocery shops, a
seven-tonne lorry, a minibus and a pick-up.

"As much as my branch manager position gave me a lot of prestige, it
no longer made sense for me to continue earning a salary that could barely
fill (up) a tank of petrol. So I left it all - a good Toyota twin cab truck,
a three-bedroomed house, with a swimming pool in a posh suburb and all the
prestige, to concentrate on my indigenous businesses."

This Zimbabwean is writing from Pretoria: "I am starting work tomorrow
exactly 12 days after having collected my quota work permit at the SA
embassy in Harare. I had to leave Zimbabwe in a huff, maybe I had no choice
or maybe I had a choice but I am just a coward."

He was responding to my piece last week, Up Close and Personal. . .in
Agony

For him, the clincher was an encounter with armed men guarding
Munhumutapa building in Harare. In his own words:

"On our way back to the hotel, I decided that as it was past seven, it
was no longer safe for us to use Kwame Nkrumah Avenue and I suggested we use
Samora Machel Avenue and this should be safe for us since there would be
police guarding Munhumutapa building. As we approached Munhumutapa building
the metal button of my jacket accidentally hit against the metal section of
the telephone substation next to the pavement. At that time the armed police
asked my wife. Ambuya, chiyi chamakanda pahwindo? (Lady, what did you just
throw at the window?)"

Here, I am inclined to say "The rest is history". But I suspect some
people will not be content until I give them what others call the "full
Monty" or the whole enchilada. But what followed was almost routine, vintage
Zimbabwean.

After a few exchanges with the soldiers, he ended up lying flat on his
belly, in front of his understandably flabbergasted wife. It was his wife's
comment later to which he thought I ought to pay special attention:

"Shamwari, iwe ne optimism yako! Let's leave the country. You see,
that policeman could just have killed you . . . just like that (snap of the
fingers? and got away with it."

Evidently, it wasn't a spur-of-the-moment decision. The couple had
been contemplating it for some time, as other couples - single men and
women, confirmed old bachelors and middle-aged spinsters and families - have
done since 2000.

Nobody with even a cursory understanding of Zanu PF politics, since
Gukurahundi, could imagine them reacting to this human haemorrhage with
anything other than "Who cares?" or "So what?"

Life in exile has never been a bed of roses, not in the Americas, in
Europe, Asia, Africa or Australasia.

Not everyone who has fled the economic and political squalor of
countries such as Zimbabwe has eventually finished up as a human Zero. The
people who escaped Nazi terror included the German-born Werner von Broun and
Albert Einstein. They became living legends in their adopted country, the
USA.

This should not encourage young Zimbabwean nerds or eggheads to flee
to South Africa in the hope that, while there, they might discover a Nobel
Prize-winning chemical that, when secreted into the womb, will ensure no
African child is born with the genes that could turn them into maniacal
dictators - although this might solve a lot of problems for the continent.

Zimbabweans have eventually done well in many fields of human
endeavour, once they have braved the scourge of xenophobia that afflicts
every country in the world.

The South Africans are divided over what status to accord Zimbabweans
escaping what has been called The Mugabe Menace: bona fide refugees or
economic asylum seekers?

So far, Zimbabweans do not enjoy the status of refugees: their country
is not in a state of civil war - well, not physically, anyway - nor has
their president declared publicly everyone who opposes his regime must be
fed to the lions in Gonarezhou.

What he has done, not in so many words, is to indicate, chillingly,
graphically, that opposing Zanu PF too openly can be very costly - at least,
to your health.

You will be starved of food, either with empty supermarket shelves or
the denial of food aid from donors.

Personally, my sympathies lie with both sides - the cowards and the
people of courage who decide to stick it out to the end.

Incidentally, I spent 17 years in another country, before 1980. I have
mixed feelings about my period there. Mostly, I wonder how I survived that
long.

saidib@standard.co.zw

Tuesday, November 14, 2017

Zimbabwe police favours the status quo


Here is a quick guide why the Zimbabwe Police leadership was not part of the security forces press conference on Monday.

 

The Status Quo Benefits the Police

Some people have joked that the police should now be renamed to Zimbabwe Revenue Police. Ideally any revenue that the police collect should be passed on to the Consolidated Revenue Fund at the Treasury but that is no longer the case as the police now retain all the monies. We all know that Zimbabwe has been a police state from the colonial times. Now the police commanders not only commands the brute police force but now they are in charge of all the revenue that the police now collects. At Beitbridge border there is a police post where all the border jumpers are required to pay a fine of R320 or US$20 and that money goes straight to the police. A bus I boarded from Pretoria to Harare on 2 October 2017 about 75% of the passengers had to pay that fine to the police. It is estimated that between 50 and 100 buses cross from South Africa into Zimbabwe each day and you can see how lucrative this is for the police.  A mere 50 metres from the border gate, there is the first traffic check point where all the cross border buses get stopped to pay the spot fine for being behind time. Obviously because of the delays at the border post each and every bus has to pay that spot fine as they cant stick to their official time table.

From Beitbridge to Harare if you travel during the day, you can encounter over 15 police check points. At each and every check point the police will charge motorists spot fines for various traffic offences.  During October 2017, I was going to Zimbabwe every week and I was once given a lift by a police officer from Beitbridge to Harare. The officer told me that they had daily targets to meet and that is why they never caution a motorist and  for any traffic offence they must collect a fine. My house about 18km from Harare city, there is at least 5 traffic check points along that short distance. If you board a minibus taxi even though legally they are only allowed to have 15 passengers, they can fit between 18 to 22 passengers per journey. What happens is that each morning they pay the spot fines to the police and they use those ticket receipts for the whole day. So in Harare and across the country, you will find the overcrowded and clearly not roadworthy  commuter taxis moving around each day and the police are not bothered as long as they have collected the fines for the day. In my view these fines are actually just taxes that the police charges for their own use. Zimbabwe being generally a peaceful country, a lot of the police officers are sent to collect revenue for the police.

We all know that Zimbabwe is now a failed state. From the little revenue that the Government gets, they try to prioritise the military but clearly due to the economic policies of the regime as well as the lack of rule of law there is no new investment in the country hence the government is living on borrowed time. Ordinary soldiers even though they get their salaries paid first ahead of all other civil servants, they still have to go and queue at the banks where there is no cash. Contrast this with the police; whilst the police officers are collecting fines for their bosses, they also get bribes. In government hospitals there are even shortages of penicillin but we can see police officers moving around in their new Israeli made Anti-riot water tanks, new Scania trucks and brand new ford pick-up trucks as they generate their own revenue. From my brief stay in Zimbabwe, I discovered that the most hated group of people where the police officers, the first lady, Jonathan Moyo and his G40. To borrow a statement coined by Secretary Hillary Clinton. I would also term all these group of people as a basket of deplorables.  Ordinary citizens now commends people who run away from the traffic police.

A look at the leadership of the police

Many years ago, a childhood friend who was working in the police protection unit which is a police unit tasked with protecting VIPs told me that the core bodyguards for Mugabe are made up mainly of his close relatives. Six years ago Mugabe promoted Innocent Matibiri a close relative to be the deputy Commissioner General and is now in charge of operations in the Zimbabwe police. So the current police leadership also has a vested personal interest in the status quo.

 

In conclusion

It’s no secret that the majority of the people will welcome a military coup but that will not be the solution. Also a Munangagwa’s presidency is not the answer. Some of us who grew up in Kwekwe where Munangagwa was the Zanu-PF member of Parliament witnessed the violence in the 1985 and 1990 general elections. We urgently need a National Transitional Authority in Zimbabwe as no meaningful election can be held in Zimbabwe. We must avoid the route that Egypt took after the demise of the Mubarak’s regime. I also watched Gwede Mantashe ANC Secretary General’s statement on Zimbabwe. May I remind ANC government and all the neighbouring countries that after former President Thabo Mbeki’s role in aiding and abetting the Mugabe’s regime in subverting the will of Zimbabwe people from the 2000 election. As Morgan Tsvangirai said Zimbabwe is no longer a foreign affairs issue for South Africa but it is now a domestic issue. The current ANC government should own up and help to solve this issue before it disintergrates further. One can read the Kamphepe report on the 2002 Zimbabwe presidential election compiled by former Deputy Chief Justice Dikgang Moseneke and Judge Sisi Kamphepe on how the elections were stolen https://mg.co.za/article/2014-11-14-khampepe-zimbabwes-2002-elections-not-free-and-fair

Friday, November 3, 2017

Happy Birthday to my best friend


 Happy birthday to my dearest Betty also known as Onita or Mai Denny  


I first saw this beauty in early 1999. One evening on my way home from work, I boarded the Chawasarira Bus from Harare City Centre to Chitungwiza. I happened to sit next to this beauty; she was sleeping half the journey. At first, I was scared to talk to her and then I was like what do I have to lose? I even tried to impress you with my newly acquired 3rd hand Ericson cellphone by phoning my mother’s home from my newly acquired Econet prepaid Buddie line and you were not impressed. Luckily you still gave me a chance, by the time you disembarked from the bus, I had your CABS head office work number and I had also given you my office telephone number at Eagle Insurance company and I challenged you to phone me at work.

The following working day, you phoned me on my office number. From then onwards we would talk over the phone for close to an hour most days. I don’t know how even now, we can always talk for hours and hours. During weekends and after work, I would phone on your father’s cellphone and ask to speak to you.  As I got to know you, I was impressed that you knew exactly what you wanted in life and you were so opinionated. One weekend around 2000-2001 you said you did not feel like going out and I should come to your parent’s home with video cassettes. I was so nervous when I thought of all those brothers of yours. We sat in the tv lounge whilst your mother was busy with her sewing machine. The first movie I think it was from Jean-Claude Van Damme and it went very well. Your father then came in and also sat in the lounge when we started playing Leon Schuster’s Panic Mechanic. I was so embarrassed when the movie started to play and I wished I could just disapper.

For the few months I stayed in Chitungwiza, I would bump into you in the bus and it was always my pleasure to offer you my seat and then continue the journey as a standing passenger. I might have hidden from you on some days when I also very tired to stand-up the whole 25km of the journey and I will spend the rest of my days making it up to you. When our relationship got serious, we would meet after work in Harare city centre upstairs at KFC Jason Moyo avenue and those days all we could afford was the ice cream.

 Up to when I met you, I had never really thought of settling down. I knew it was time to introduce you to the beautiful and strong women in my life, my sisters, my aunt in Sunningdale and my mother. Growing up, I remember some of the stories whenever I went to the village during school holidays about marrying someone from Masvingo and my eldest cousin had married from Masvingo. When I met you I did not care what my relatives would say, I was okay with marrying Wezhira. Marrying you is the best decision that I made in my life. We share many interests such as reading widely and the love for travelling.

We have been through so many changes in our life. Remember the days we started staying together as a couple in Avondale in September 2001 when we did not have much and we could not even afford a fridge and then moving houses, relocating to Bulawayo and finally having to leave our country of birth to come to South Africa. Thank you for being a pillar of strength. They say you can be as good as the company that you keep, thank you for being in my board of directors and I know any idea that I come up with must always stand up to your usual scrutiny. Thanks for trying to make me a better man and I hope to listen more to you. I have learnt a lot from you and at times, I have to remind you that you are no longer working at CABS mortgage department as you are more forceful that I always have to pay my debts on time.

Thank you Manyoni for making me the happiest man alive in the short 16 years that we have been married. Thank you for being a wonderful mother to our boys. Thank you for also being a mother to my brothers and sisters, I owe you a lot for taking in my siblings into our home at their greatest time of need when my mother also followed my father to a better place. I know you did not have to, you just did and you never complained about it. I believe my parents were able to rest in peace knowing that you and I would take care of their children.

May the good lord bless you, make all your dreams come true and give you an awesome life ahead.

Happy Birthday baby Ra Dabbie
 

Sunday, October 15, 2017

Response to Nicolette

Disclaimer: This message is based on my personal experience in the insurance industry and is not affiliated to any firm or any individual.

https://www.facebook.com/FinancialFitnessBunny/videos/1189749327823574

Dear Nicolette

 

I watched your video on Wednesday 11 October 2017 whilst sitting in a bus at Mbare Musika bus terminus in Harare on my way to our rural home. You know the price of data in Zimbabwe is actually a human rights issue, I mean how can they charge so much in an impoverished country? Any way the topic you were discussing interested me very much and I had no choice to but to watch until the end and in the process my battery and data were drained and I promised to respond when I came back to SA.

 

I think you were treated unfairly. I do not consider my- self an expert in Insurance but I know one or two things about insurance.  I worked for almost 20 years in the insurance industry and I left the industry beginning of October 2017. Firstly I worked for almost 10 years in the Zimbabwe Insurance industry starting in underwriting, then claims, then briefly as an insurance broker and finally as a middle manager in charge of underwriting and claims. I also passed my Insurance fellowship exams in 2005. In 2007 when the Zimbabwe economic situation became unbearable, I migrated to South Africa and I got employed as a claims advisor in an insurance firm and I worked there for just over 10 years. My role in SA involved mainly business claims and I also did personal claims for about 3 years and also briefly acted as a claims team manager for 2 months. As someone who is not currently affiliated to any insurance firm, I will try to be impartial as much as possible.

I would have liked to have read a copy of your policy wording before responding to your video. In any case, I will use the knowledge I have gained from my insurance studies, Multi-Mark policy wording which is a standardised policy wording that the insurance industry used in the past until the Competition authorities discouraged the practice and I will use the knowledge I gained in the claims environment of the 5 insurance companies that I worked for plus the practice of many more insurance companies I worked closely with as an insurance broker.

In general cellphone and other portable items that you take away from your home/house are covered on an All Risks Basis. Such items include your camera, laptop, jewellery on a person, watches, clothing such as your kids school uniform or your clothing that you take away with you from home e.g baggage that you take with you for an overseas holiday.  All Risks cover when you compare it with your household furniture has important differences.

  • Items on All Risks  has  a wider cover e.g you will be covered for accidental damage, theft e.t.c.  When you read the cover on All Risks the defined events are simply listed as “ Loss of or damage to item”, which in theory means anything that happens to the item is covered unless if it is specifically excluded. On the other hand the household policy (House contents policy) and the Home Owners (Buildings policy) only lists specific perils such as falling trees, fire, lightning, explosion, earth quakes etc. So for a perils policy you are only covered for the listed perils subject to the conditions, general exceptions, clauses, warranties, specific exceptions e.t.c
  • An All Risks policy covers you on a world- wide basis e.g if you take your cellphone to Ghana with you it will be automatically covered as it is covered anywhere in the world. Whereas your TV in your house will only be covered at the address noted on your policy schedule (of course if you take it for repairs there might be extensions to cover you for that)
  • Cover on an All Risks Basis is normally more expensive as it has more wider cover than the normal Perils policy, hence the cellphone cover is normally very expensive as well as the Comprehensive Motor Insurance cover that is also on an All Risks Basis.

Another very important issue to consider is that insurance is only part of the Risk Management equation. In general individuals and firms are exposed to risks, e.g risks of theft, fire, liability, reputational damages e.t.c. After having analysed the risks an individual will decide on what to do with the risks they are faced with. The decision might be to transfer the risks to the insurance company in return the individual will pay a premium to the insurance company. In most cases the insurance company will require an individual to pay an excess which in turn means that the individual is then forced to retain part of the risks. In other cases the individual might decide to retain the risks and they will try to mitigate the risks e.g by employing a guard, putting a tracker on a vehicle, erecting burglar bars around the premises e.t.c. Also note by mitigating the risks, an individual might actually be able to get insurance at much lower insurance premiums.

 

Coming to Cell phone Insurance

My experience with Cell phone insurance is that it is a very expensive insurance cover to get. I remember around 1998-1999 in Zimbabwe when the premiums for the cellphones increased drastically to match the losses experienced.  Also part of being financially savvy is to always consider the cost versus benefit. I am a stingy man and I do not buy cell phone on contract, I only buy a phone up to R3 000.00 and I use pre-paid (I used to use contract cellphone when the company was paying the bill). Because of the relatively cheap phones I use, it is not economical for me to insure the cellphone.  One must always consider the premiums that you are charged on a cellphone together with the excess that you will be required to pay in the event of a claim. For example if the premiums that you contribute over say 12 to 18 months (a normal life span of a cellphone) plus the excess exceeds 50% of the value of the cellphone, the question is, is it rational to insure the cellphone?

Whether your cellphone is insured or not, you should always know the IMEI number of your cellphone which is a unique number to your phone (you might consider it to be the VIN number of your phone). You get the IMEI number of your phone by Dialling *#06#. Should your cellphone get stolen or lost you will need the IMEI number in order to block the cellphone with network company and also to open a case with the police. My understanding is that once a cellphone is blocked it cannot be used again in the country. It is very important for everyone to block any lost or stolen cellphone as this will discourage the theft of the cellphones. I suspect that the blocked cellphones can be used in other countries (those who have the information might comment on this) in which case SADC, Interpol and Cellphone companies in neighbouring countries might cooperate in the same way stolen cars are recovered in neighbouring countries. Also as individuals we should desist from buying stolen property. Cellphone theft is a big issue in that it drives cellphone premiums high, theft of cellphones are often accompanied by violence. Our home is around Pretoria Central and I normally leave my cellphone at home after having been a victim of a cellphone mugging about two years ago.

I know there is a perception that insurance companies thrive on consumer ignorance. For your own information the industry is well regulated in South Africa, consider this statement from the then Minister of finance Mr. Trevor Manuel on the launch of the Ombudsman for Financial Service Providers, “The era of properly regulated financial services has dawned, which should banish the dark ages of non-disclosure, unreadable fine print, and mis-selling.”. From my experience when an operator realises that a claim is going to be rejected, he or she will first get permission from the supervisor. Once the supervisor agrees with the rejection, an official letter is then sent out to the client  mentioning the reasons for the rejection. The rejection letter will also spell out the recourse the client has e.g. appealing internally to the company in writing if the client is still not satisfied they will then refer the matter to the Ombudsman. It is important to realise that the ombudsman is very impartial and there is no cost to the client involved during the process.  Still if the client is not satisfied he or she will then approach the courts.

In your case Nicolette, I suggest you first get the letter with the rejection reasons in writing and then pick up a phone and ask to speak to a claims manager at the insurance company and if you are not satisfied then approach the insurance ombudsman. Believe you have nothing to lose by following this route. The insurance firms like any business they are also worried about their reputations.

 

My general observations from my experience in the industry

  • Clients must always be honest. Insurance is based mainly on the law of contract hence it is always imperative to be truthful and disclose all relevant facts when you enter into the insurance contract and also at the time of claim. You should rather shop around for the best terms based on the correct facts.
  • Ask questions if you are not sure. You are actually the boss you are the reason why that insurance company is in business. When a person finances a car they are in a hurry to get insurance and drive the car. Make sure that that you can afford to pay the quoted excess in the event of a claim. (Chances are if you can’t afford normal car instalment and normal insurance the vehicle might be beyond your budget).
  • Financial literacy is key, some cars are in demand such that you will buy them at a value that is more than their replacement values. For example if your vehicle’s retail value is only R200 000.00 yet you buy the vehicle for R250 000.00, should that vehicle be stolen the next day the insurance company will only pay R200 000.00 which is the value of the vehicle. Make sure you take credit shortfall cover which is offered by both the insurance companies and also through the car dealership when you sign the hire purchase agreement.
  • Now and again maybe after a year talk to your insurance company try to negotiate a better deal e.g maybe lowering your higher excess based on the good experience you have had with an insurance company.
  • Minimise your risks. We all know which areas are more risky when it comes to insurance for example if you have a tracking device in your vehicle everytime you drive to that area they phone you to warn you. Chances are if you stay in that area your insurance premiums will also be high, this is a fact of statistics and not race, you might need to move to a new area that is cheaper for you in the long run. We all know which cars are prone to theft and hijackings, chances are if you buy that car it will be very expensive to buy and the insurance premiums will be unbearable. So you much choose wisely that is part of being financially savvy.

Thank you very much for your work in educating people about financial literacy.

 

Regards

 

Dabson

Sunday, October 1, 2017

It is not goodbye, it is see you later

Photo taken at work by Kim Naidoo
After 10 years, one month and two days, today is my last day at OUTsurance. At the beginning of 2017, I knew I could not continue and it was time to try new things. We all need encouragement and special thanks to my friend and neighbour at work, Kim Naidoo who kept on encouraging me to wait until we reached our 10 years of service. OUTsurance is very special to me, more so due to the fact that I got this job a week after I left Zimbabwe and decided to settle in South Africa. I know I will never forget you guys, for you have enriched my life.


Downloaded from Pinterest.com
 I was born and a raised in an environment where the dominant religions were African religion and Christianity. During my 10 years here at OUTsurance, I did interact with work colleagues, customers and suppliers who come from different backgrounds from my own. Indeed South Africa is a rainbow nation and I am proud to call South Africa my home. Even though we might look different, practice different religions, are believers or non- believers or regardless of our individual marital status. I was amazed to realise that most of the values that were instilled in me growing up in Zimbabwe are the same values shared by people of different backgrounds here in South Africa. I am reminded by what President Obama said during his Cairo speech when he said, “ ..all of us share common aspirations - to live in peace and security; to get an education and to work with dignity; to love our families, our communities, and our God. These things we share. This is the hope of all humanity.”

It’s not goodbye, but see you later. I hope to still meet you guys whether it is in the streets of Pretoria or Harare. 
To my friends on PBS, keep on being Awesome and know that each day counts and one must always put their best foot forward each and every day. Remember it always averages out!
Photo taken at our Zimbabwe home by my good friend Mereka Maruwira

Let’s keep on dreaming freaking BIG and learning from our mistakes. Although we can’t always control our environment and how other people treat us, one must try by all means not to become a victim for in most cases we alone as individuals have the ultimate power to choose what we do next.

Cheers