Monday, May 18, 2020

IS A CAR AN INVESTMENT OR ASSET IN SOUTH AFRICA?

Disclaimer- I am not a financial advisor, I speak from my own personal experiences on what I encountered in Zimbabwe & South Africa during the last 22 years in the Insurance industry. I do have an accounting degree as well An Advanced Diploma in Insurance Management ( Fellowship Diploma) from The Insurance Institute of South Africa.

During the Zuma years especially around 2015 up to the time that he fired Nhlanhla Nene as the finance minister some of us who lived under Robert Mugabe years in Zimbabwe from 1997 when Zim dollar to 2008 when hundreds of thousands of Zimbabweans left for South Africa started to panic.

I saw the same signs I saw in Zimbabwe. I had joined the insurance industry in Zimbabwe at the end of 1997 and I can write books about the ravages of inflation. In a normal economy a vehicle is supposed to lose value and it is not considered an asset. Assets such as vehicles somehow traces the value of US$ as vehicles are imported. It is no secret that the Rand has lost its value over the last 10 years. In 2009 when we started building our house in Zimbabwe, for every R100 I could get $12.50 and now it is more like $7.

So my first car I bought in South Africa was a Toyota Tazz at the end of 2007 on finance for a price of R54 000. My monthly installment was around R1 200, I sold it in 2016 for R 32 500.00, after driving it for 9 years. When I left Zimbabwe in 2007 my allocated company car was a 2002 Toyota Hilux KZTE 3.0 D d/cab similar to the one in the photo below. You will be surprised that this 18 year old vehicle is being advertised for R139 000. Incidentally I once considered buying this vehicle in 2007 for the same price when I came to South Africa.

In 2014, I bought my first Hyundai H100 Bakkie for R90 000 on finance. A similar 2008 Bakkie is now being advertised for R100 000.00. Of course when you consider the time value of money R100 000 in 2020 is not the same as R90 000 in 2014. My point is that you can finance a car and use it ( very few of us can afford to buy a car cash) and still be able to dispose it for a decent some. With the state of public transport a vehicle is a necessity especially if you have a family. Maybe you wish to apply for home loan and one of the question is do you own a vehicle? Is the vehicle paid up? What is the value of the vehicle? Food for thought.

I don’t recommend buying a car on residual finance, there is no free lunch in this world.





Sunday, May 17, 2020

ZIMBABWEANS ARE TOO INDIVIDUALISTIC, HENCE WE WILL SUFFER LONGER

 
I always remember this scenario, from 2000 onwards Zimbabwe started experiencing fuel shortages due to the continued devaluation of the Zimbabwean dollar. Around 2005 we were renting a flat next to Marlborough Civic Centre. So petrol was expected to be delivered at a fuel station along Harare Drive not far from home. We spent almost two days queuing in an orderly way. One of the guys in the queue I discovered was my sister’s boss at Red Star Wholesalers head office. We sort of became friends with the group and we got along very well. On the day petrol was delivered there was chaos those people you thought were your friends didn’t care whether you got fuel or not, cars got scratched in the process. During that time is when corruption got entrenched in the Zimbabwean psyche. As long as zvangu zvaita I don’t care about you became the attitude.

This week at our complex in Pretoria there was a police van on a purely civil matter within the body corporate. Our white controlled body corporate fired cleaners and they appointed a white company to provide cleaning services. We opposed the move to no avail. We have a long running dispute with the body corporate and they are using tactics to delay the AGM where we want to vote them out. In true South African style the only route left is protest. Protest is the language of the unheard and South Africans use it effectively๐Ÿ™๐Ÿฟ When I first arrived in South Africa, I never understood why people protested so much but now after nearly 13 years in South Africa, I now realise it is very effective. I remember last year driving into Cape Town along N2 traffic was at a standstill at Paarl for almost 4 hours as community members were protesting. I am sure Zanu-PF is nervous as thousands of Zimbabweans who have lost their jobs due to COVID-19 are making their way back home.

In Zimbabwe the government banned minibus taxis for the last 7 weeks, just imagine if that had happened in South Africa there would be mayhem. Even the lockdown in South Africa people are no longer complying. The problem in Zimbabwe is that we are not united and we look at our problems in isolation and we are easy to be divided and then be ruled. Taxi drivers, vendors, farmers etc don’t realise that they have the common enemy in the misrule of Zanu-PF.

If opposition supporters, taxi drivers, farmers, vendors, workers, students etc united under a proactive leadership, Zanu-PF would not last a day. The truth is that Zanu-PF cannot put everyone in prison.

Saturday, May 2, 2020

REMEMBERING DJ PETER JOHNS & RADIO 3

I still remember the first time Radio 3 became a 24 hour station in 1997. I was teaching at Kambarami Secondary School just outside Murehwa Center. I was renting a room at the pink house from Mudhara Ndorochena at Murehwa. I was busy with my accounting studies with Chartered Institute of Management Accountants. I went to the then brand new beautiful Westgate Shopping Center in Harare and bought myself a radio cassette radio player from Discom shop. 3 years later I would join AIG Zimbabwe at their Westgate offices.

Back in Murehwa I would wake-up early around 4am to study listening to Radio 3. Growing up in the 80s and early 90s, adults would mostly switch the radio to Radio 2 which alternated between Shona and Ndebele and we were forced to listen to it. The fact that I can understand Ndebele (Zulu) is thanks to Radio 2. In high school we started listening to the mainly American music and a bit of British music on Radio 3. Saturday evenings were special with the reggae session. On New Year we would listen to the top 100 songs, in 1995, I Swear was the best song๐Ÿ‘Œ๐Ÿฟ

When I started working in 1996 I would go to the flea market in Union Avenue and bought cassettes from American, Canadian and British singers. I liked one or two songs from local artists but not much to buy their music. End of 1997, I got a permanent job in Harare and I eventually opened an account with Greatermans Stores, I would go to Spinalong in Miekle stores and bought cassettes from international stars that was being played on Radio 3.

In 1999 after a very short stay in Unit J, Chitungwiza where I met my wife in early 1999, there was an advert for a 2 room cottage in Avondale behind St Anne’s Hospital, I went to view the place. It turned out the block of flats belonged to ZBC employees and the flats had been sold to employees. The lady who prepared the lease was working for Radio 1 and she would shortly leave for Canada. I bought a Sharp CD player from Clicks. I stayed in Avondale for 4 years and the place was very convenient as it was a walking distance to Avondale shopping center were I went every weekend for movies.

After 2000 elections, Jonathan Moyo became the minister of information and started making changes to state media and introduced local content. I stopped listening to the radio and I would play my cassettes at home. I never liked the new local music. In 2002 I would get my first car and I would play my cassettes in the car. Later I started subscribing to DSTV and I would watch MTV then it only played music. My neighbour whose garden flat was attached to my cottage Mai Daisy was a producer of the 8pm ZBC News complained to me that Jonathan Moyo was directly involved in this propaganda news that was being churned out on ZTV.

In 2005, I got a company car a Toyota Hilux double cab with a CD car radio player. After I became Bulawayo Branch Manager in 2006, my friend Stanley Nyatala came from Chinhoyi and we drove to Beitbridge. He introduced me to Jacaranda FM and I fell in love with the station. I looked forward to going to Beitbridge so that I would listen to Jacaranda FM. On the way to Bulawayo, I would listen to Jacaranda all the way to Gwanda ๐Ÿ‘Œ๐ŸฟJacaranda FM played the music I grew up listening on Radio 3. Up to this day I listen to Jacaranda on weekends and during the long drives to Beitbridge on my way home to Zimbabwe.

In 2006,I drove to Pretoria for the first time. My youngest sister took me to Menlyn Shopping Center. Near to the entrance, there was Reliable Music Warehouse. I bought so many cassettes in that store. I have no problem with buying 3 things; vehicles, books and music. Radio 3 gave us magic ๐Ÿ™๐Ÿฟ I thank it’s DJs such as Peter Jonhs, James Maridadi, Kudzi Marudza (Kudzi once came you our flat in 2008 to visit other Zimbabweans I shared the flat with in Pretoria) and many others. Davis Mugadza every morning would play a song by Regina Belle, “be in love again”๐Ÿ‘Œ๐Ÿฟ

Saturday, April 25, 2020

ZIMBABWEANS IN SOUTH AFRICA WE ARE NOT BETTER BLACKS, WE ARE JUST DESPERATE

The situation has changed for foreigners since 2007 when I relocated to South Africa. In my first week, I went to three different interviews and I signed my employment offer letter on the 8th day of arriving in South Africa. At that time many corporates could still employ foreigners without IDs. After the 2008 financial crisis I started noticing changes as many corporates no longer employed foreigners without IDs.

Some companies will now only employ a person who became a citizen prior to 1994. The situation extends to many fields for example it is very difficult for a foreigner to secure articles training contracts that are required for a person to become a registered lawyer or to become a Chartered Accountant. The situation is different in the unskilled and semi-skilled sectors. It is no coincidence that Minister Tito Mboweni specifically mentioned waiters.

In Zimbabwe civil servants currently earn around R1 000.00. A farm worker in South Africa who earns a gazetted monthly wage of just over R3 000 is earning more than what the Zimbabwean government pays its doctors. Due to this desperation Zimbabweans will come and outbid South Africans in the unskilled and semi-skilled jobs such as truck drivers, domestic employees, supermarket and hardware workers, security guards, waiters, petrol attendants, casual construction workers, informal jobs etc.

As I went through social media comments after what Minister Mboweni said yesterday, many Zimbabweans were saying employers prefer Zimbabweans and Malawians for those jobs because they are hard workers. I don’t agree with that, before we had influx of foreigners South Africans were doing those jobs for years. The only issue now is that there are foreigners willing to accept unfavorable employment conditions and very low pay. In Zimbabwe when the economy was doing well especially in the 80s, Mozambicans and Malawians used to be employed mainly as farm workers, plantation workers, domestic workers and mine workers. The world over menial jobs are snapped up by desperate and mainly undocumented immigrants.

The gazetted minimum wage of domestic workers is over R3 000 per month yet thousands of Zimbabweans are employed in South Africa earning R1 500 and working very long hours and at times going for weeks without off days. If you go to a number of Spar shops the situation is the same. In many trucking companies especially those that do cross borders they mainly employ foreigners because they are the only ones desperate to accept harsh employment conditions of working long hours and being paid mainly commission.

In restaurants waiters are not paid a salary by their employers instead they survive on the tips paid by clients. I found out that if you included the tip when you swipe your card, the restaurant will not pay the waiter the full tip and now I carry cash to pay the waiter directly and then swipe the rest for the meal. Waiters also work very long hours. It’s no secret that very few South Africans will accept those exploitive employment conditions in the restaurant industry.

It is illegal to employ foreigners in the security guards industry, however there are loopholes that enable foreigners to be employed illegally in the industry at very low salaries and exploitive conditions. Some security companies employ foreigners for wages as low as R1 500 per month yet the official wages is almost 3 times that. Security guards are supposed to work 4 days, 12 hour shifts and rest for another 4 days. Foreigners are made to work continuously without taking any off days.

The Labour Relations Act specifically covers all employees including illegal immigrants, if you have time you can study the case Discovery Health Ltd v CCMA & others. According to section 23 of The Constitution everyone has the right to fair labour practices. Most illegal immigrants are not aware of their rights so they endure exploitation and by accepting rock bottom remuneration and exploitive employment conditions they disadvantage black South Africans who have to compete for such benefits thereby increasing resentment further. I once read a story of a Limpopo commercial farmer, who would employ illegal immigrants as farm workers and when it came to paying their wages, he would cause them to be deported without pay.

You begin to see why there is resentment towards foreigners in the townships and informal sectors. Poor South Africans doesn’t have much bargaining power because there are hundreds of thousands of undocumented African immigrants ready to replace them at less than 50% of the gazetted wages.

The resentment also creeps in to the middle class. In many big corporates they have to follow employment equity legislation, there is very few foreigners employed as compared to the sectors I mentioned above. Promotions in the corporate sectors also normally follow employment equity. Because there are very few immigrants it means a few immigrants also rise through the ranks of management. The biggest beneficiary of employment equity legislation has been White women and Indians and not Africans and Coloureds citizens.

About 10 years ago at work a Zimbabwean was promoted into management, I was passing by a black South African lady who was then our diversity chairperson. The words she used to describe that promotion was full of hate, she said the appointment didn’t count. I understand why she felt that ways,26 years after attaining political freedom, blacks and Coloureds are still not well represented in in most sectors of the economy except maybe in State owned enterprises and public service. It seems to me she would have stomached that appointment going to a white male instead of an African immigrant.

Last year there was an incident at University of Cape Town where Dr Shose Kessi a black Tanzanian lady was voted as a new Dean, a black South African Dr Lwazi Lushaba voiced his disappointment that a black South African lady had lost that appointment to a foreigner and only got 27% of the vote. Dr Lushaba was reprimanded and was accused as being Xenophobic. I think we need to look into that from another angle. The pace of transformation has been very slow in these previously white Universities and now this appointment now goes to African immigrants at the expense of black South Africans.

Around 2014-2015 during another phase of Xenophobic attacks, a workmate who is married to a Zimbabwean man was visibly upset coming from the balcony during her lunch break, she was mentioning her husband’s name saying where do they want me to put him. I then asked my then boss what had happened, it turned out that some of the workmates had mentioned that all foreigners must go back to their countries of origin. Being married to a Zimbabwean that lunchtime conversation made her quite upset.

In early 2013 whilst waiting for my permanent resident permit, my family had gone back to Zimbabwe and I was considering going back home for good if we did not get our permits. I would go to see my family in Zimbabwe every two weeks. On this Sunday afternoon I was given a lift by a gentleman from Musina to Pretoria. The guy was coming from inspecting his franchise store in Musina, he told me he was director in a government department. He started telling me how he hated Nigerians and every time he sees a project proposal with a South African partnering a Nigerian on his desk he doesn’t approve it. I figured out he hated other Africans as well.

South Africa is experiencing its worst unemployment levels. The unemployment of black youth according to Stats SA is over 53%, so it makes sense that it has to prioritise its citizens, now people openly blame foreigners for crime and taking away their jobs. Some accuse foreigners of taking South African women. I remember in the 2017 Xenophobic attacks, people marched from townships to Sunnyside were many foreigners stay, people were querying why foreigners stayed in the flats. Police had to intervene before violence broke out between foreigners and citizens.

Former Johannesburg Mayor Herman Mashaba would periodically accuse African migrants for various crimes and he has a huge following from black South Africans who ordinarily wouldn’t vote DA. I expect that Mashaba’s political movement will be anti African immigrants and he will be continuing his rhetoric against Africans immigrants . As the ANC government fight to win back Gauteng Metros things are beginning to change. Many Zimbabweans who were employed as teachers by the government has had their contracts terminated.

There is talk of putting quotas on the number of foreigners who can be employed by trucking companies, restaurants, Spar Shops, commercial farms. There is push to have Spaza shops owned by citizens. There was talk of amending Refugees laws to take away the right to work from asylum seekers. The outlook for African immigrants is very bleak until the South African economy starts to grow again. I hope the South African government can still renew the 200 000 Zimbabwean special dispensation permits that are expiring next year. The current economic situation cannot afford to absorb such a large number back into the system.

No doubt Zimbabwean migrants are watching all this with a lot of uneasiness. Some will hope for the best, however hope is not a strategy. People need to plan. For a long time Zimbabweans in South Africa seemed to think the situation in Zimbabwe doesn’t affect them and have not been going home to vote, that must change.http://kanyokad.blogspot.com/2019/08/as-zimbabweans-do-we-deserve-our.html
 

Wednesday, April 22, 2020

IS ZIMBABWE NOW A DE FACTO PROVINCE OF SOUTH AFRICA?


Today you can drive from Port Elizabeth, over Orange River, past Bloemfontein and arrive in Johannesburg without needing a passport. A lot of people don’t know that those were separate colonies (countries). If Smuts had not succeeded you would have crossed 3 borders and needed a passport. After successfully bringing the 4 colonies as one country, in 1922 Jan Smuts tried to bring in Rhodesia as the 5th province of South Africa and in a referendum a narrow majority of 2 785 white Rhodesians refused.

Years after Apartheid became official policy in South Africa, in Rhodesia the government of Ian Smith followed a similar policy to Apartheid when it came to segregation of Europeans, blacks, coloureds and Indians. South Africa was the main trading partner of Rhodesia and is still the main trading partner of Zimbabwe. In 1976 whilst Ian Smith’s government with the support of South Africa was fighting a bitter war against guerilla movements led separately by Joshua Nkomo and Robert Mugabe. Prime Minister John Vorster decided to abandon Rhodesia, many white Rhodesians call it the great betrayal as they felt that it turned the tide against the racist government of Rhodesia in the war.

After independence in 1980, tens of thousands of white Rhodesians trekked to South Africa. Thousands of Ndebele men kept going to South Africa mainly to seek employment and to run away from the Gukurahundi Massacre of the 80s. After the chaotic land reform from 2000 and the accompanying economic decline in Zimbabwe, tens of thousands of skilled Zimbabweans started applying for work permits to relocate to South Africa.

When I went submit my work permit around June 2007 at the South African embassy in Harare, there were hundreds of people in the queue. I saw guys that I had worked with 10 years before when I was a teacher. Tens of thousands more came on travellers visas and started working mainly as waiters and farm workers as undocumented immigrants. I remember a lady I gave a lift in Gweru early 2007 who had quit her job as a bank teller at Stanbic Bank and was working as a waiter in Pretoria and was earning around R4 000.00. My salary then as a branch manager was equivalent of R1 000.00.

After the 2008 election, the violent election run off, the economic crisis in Zimbabwe hundreds of thousands of Zimbabweans flocked to South Africa. I remember in 2008 driving from Beitbridge crowds walking along N1 between Musina and Louis Trichardt. During the Cholera outbreak in Zimbabwe, government of Thabo Mbeki stopped deporting Zimbabweans that time and they admitted sick Zimbabweans in hospitals in Musina in order to control the spread of Cholera. The Zimbabwe Special dispensation permit was unveiled by South Africa and over 200 000 were issued.

Now Zimbabwe depends almost entirely on South Africa, over a million Zimbabweans in South Africa send money and groceries to Zimbabwe for their families. Zimbabwe relies on electricity from Eskom to help plug the shortages. The Zimbabwean government is at the mercy of South African government and not the Chinese as some think.

Do you agree that Zimbabwe is now a de facto province of South Africa ?

Tuesday, April 21, 2020

JOHANNESBURG PARK STATION STORIES - A LESSON IN HUMILITY



I am scared of visiting Park Station because I always run into someone from my past. In 2008, MaNyoni was going back home to Zimbabwe and I drove her to Park Station to catch a bus to Harare. As we stood in the queue waiting for her to board the bus, a former workmate from Zimbabwe greeted me and with pity in his eyes said, “Oh I heard you are now working in a call centre”.

We had been managers together in Zimbabwe, I was on a higher level than him. He told me that his contract in Angola had ended and he was on his way back to Zimbabwe. At our company they were recruiting and after sending their CVs to recruiters, two of my former workmates from Zimbabwe had already come for interviews and one had started his job. I couldn’t ask this guy in front of me to send me his CV as it was clear that working in the call centre was beneath him. The truth was in the call centre I now earned 18 times more than what I earned in Zimbabwe as a middle level manager.

After he was gone MaNyoni said, “ Akunzirwa tsitsi wena”(He felt pity for you). The following year when we built our house in Zimbabwe MaNyoni teased me and said, “ look what the little money from the call centre has done for us”. A year after that when I bought my first Mercedes she said the same. The moral of the story is never look down upon someone based on your pre-conceived ideas. There were many times I wanted to change jobs and I have always been told, we can’t afford you.

Society has taught us to look down on people based on their titles and appearances and we don’t know how much we miss out. When I worked in Zimbabwe many people did not know how powerful my PA/ secretaries were as their opinions mattered so much to me and I saw the same with my bosses’ PAs and I always showed them respect. Never disrespect anyone, another day in the supermarket I was paying for groceries at the cashier and after greeting her, she asked me if I knew that if I bought two of these items I would get 50% off. I thanked her and she waited patiently as I went back to the shelves.

Many people have domestic employees who cook for them and take care of their kids, if you treat them as animals imagine how they will treat your kids some who can’t even talk yet. Some of the wisest people, I have met did not go to school for example my maternal grandfather. When I grew tobacco in Zimbabwe in the 2016-2017 farming season the people I relied on could barely write their own names but they had so much knowledge and I learnt a lot from them, those men and women are walking encyclopedias on tobacco farming

Thursday, April 9, 2020

TRAVEL DIAIRIES- AN UNFORGETTABLE HOLIDAY BULAWAYO, HWANGE NATIONAL PARK AND VICTORIA FALLS 2002



The second holiday was in September 2002. Our white wedding was on 14 December and two weeks after that we were expecting our first child. We decided to travel to Bulawayo, Hwange and Victoria Falls before the wedding and the baby. The day of the travel, I got a lift to Murewa to meet my manager.

At the end of 2001 I had opened a shop in the village of Bokwe where my mum was born. When the neighbouring white commercial farmer in Virginia, Macheke was removed during land reform I had taken over the farm store at Paradise farm (known as Masvaisvai farm to locals). I now had two stores.

We boarded a Bulawayo bound bus in the afternoon behind Sheraton hotel. I grew up in Kwekwe in the 80s and most school holidays we would take the Tauya Bus to Harare and then Shiriyekutanga buses to Jekwa, Murewa. One of the Shiriyekutanga drivers was a relative sekuru January Nyawata. All the buses from Kwekwe to Harare charged $7 except Tauya which charged $6, incidentally I learnt my first big English word “Emergency” in Tauya coach & Shiriyekutanga buses around 1983 ๐Ÿ™ˆ.

We got to Gweru and the bus driver said hr was not proceeding to Bulawayo, we got cramped in a minibus tax. The conditions in the taxi were not favorable to a pregnant MaNyoni. We arrived in Bulawayo around midnight and hired a taxi to Holiday Inn. I love Bulawayo a lot. Every two years the insurance industry held an annual sporting weekend in Bulawayo and I never missed any one of those company paid holidays๐Ÿ‘Œ๐Ÿฟ. I will write a book about those Bulawayo trips one day.

Around mid morning we went to Renkini looking for buses to Hwange and we were directed I think to then New Nkulumane Complex. We boarded a Kukura Kurerwa Volvo bus. We were dropped off on the road leading to Hwange airport. We boarded the game view Toyota Landcruiser to our lodge. I never missed any one of those game drives๐Ÿ‘Œ๐Ÿฟ

Early one morning close to Hwange camp main gate, I saw a pack of wild dogs and within five seconds they were gone. Years later we visited Kruger National Park and I never saw as many animals as I did in Hwange. Our lodge was nearer a water hole and hundreds of elephants would come by๐Ÿ‘Œ๐Ÿฟ

On the second day one of the families from South Africa was going back,there were only 6 chalets, we drove with them to Hwange airport. The family had come with their own plane. A fun fact the runway at Hwange National Park at 4600m is one of the longest in the world nand I was told it can accommodate the NASA Space shuttle on the way back to earth.

After 4 days in Hwange in September 2002, we were dropped off at Cross Dete and got transport to Victoria Falls. Victoria Falls has the same effect on me like Durban, Phuket or Cape Town, I will never get bored of those places no matter how many times I visit them.


For the first two nights we stayed in a self-catering two bedroom at a flat at a place called Tshulu Tsha Nabe. For the last two nights we checked into The Kingdom Hotel. I have since stayed in dozens of hotels but Kingdom Hotel remains my best ever hotel๐Ÿ‘Œ๐Ÿฟ Every time I visit Vic Falls I go to The Kingdom hotel.

After four nights in Victoria Falls we decided that we would come back come back the following year. In November 2002, I started a new job as a junior manager and the job came with a company car a Mazda 323. Even then there were fuel shortages in Zimbabwe and Zimbabwe Sun hotels in Victoria Falls had advertised that they were providing fuel.

We drove from Harare and stayed at Rainbow Hotel in Bulawayo. They were busy renovating Rainbow Bulawayo. It seems the hotel had double booked our room because later that night other people opened the door with their card and luckily we had blocked the door from inside with that metal blocker. There was fuel in Bulawayo and we refueled and drove to Victoria Falls. After spending six days in Victoria Falls we approached the hotel wanting to buy fuel and there was none. Luckily I had carried a 20 litre of petrol.

We managed to drive slowly from Victoria Falls back to Bulawayo. I estimate that we only had 27 to 30 litres. For that journey. We stayed at Rainbow Bulawayo again and got fuel back to Harare. When I became Bulawayo branch manager from 2006-2007 I was in charge of the agency in Victoria Falls and Hwange so I would drive to Victoria Falls.